Negotiation calculation script is bad

Vali

Hi.
In the first and second EG rounds, where are only one good, supplies an coins, you must make script to spend first ONLY coins, after that only supplies and third time good.
Thanks

andrgin

To be honest I never thought someone will need a helper for the negotiations with only 3 goods…

Vali

Hi andrgin
Yes indeed, is no needed for someone who play FoE for some time. But for someone who barely starts, and does not understand very well negotiations, will do what FoeHelper shows. And will spend some goods without needed….
IMO, even only on coins and supplies, the first thing which must fill, must be only coins, and after that supplies. I think most of players have a stock with coins greater than supplies.

PS: Sorry for my english, is not my daily language..

KRUPP

Mag schon sein, das niemand einen Helfer bei 3 Gütern braucht, es schaltet ihn aber auch niemand extra deshalb ab.
Von daher macht es schon einen komischen Eindruck, das der Verhandlungsassistend, wie vom Eröffner beschrieben reagiert 🙁

JPR

More concerning to me is why it almost always fails when the negotiation has more than 5 different goods to select from. Other than that, I really like this feature.

Beta_Wolf

JPR The chances of a successful negotiation are just lower when there are more different goods.

andrgin

The negotiation helper always picks the guess with the highest chance of solving the negotiation. There is no way to improve this chance.

Wanderer99

I just want to provide some feedback on this. I always use this tool with the Extra Turn from Tavern.
I haven’t counted, but I can say I don’t think I’ve had to use diamonds more than maybe 5-6 times. And I may have used the tool lets say 150 times. I would think thats very successful statistically speaking.

andrgin

From my experience for 3 turns the tool is not so much better than doing it manually because only round2 is where you can make smart choices (first round is always 5 different goods and last round is always “pick a possible solution”).
For 4 turns the negotiation helper is a lot better than doing it manually (at least for me).